An Evertonian website

Not Waving but Drowning

That sound you can hear is laughter. People laughing. People laughing at Everton.

Who can blame them?

The club where nothing positive ever seems to happen is becoming a laughing stock once again.

When The Friedkin Group arrived in December 2024, many of us thought we’d finally left the batshit-crazy situations behind. Stability and growth were the buzzwords being thrown around. Most fans were willing to forgive the frustrations of last summer’s transfer window. The failure to sign a right-back was met with a degree of understanding and acceptance.

Then January came and went, and we still hadn’t addressed the position. Eyebrows were raised, but the excuses were familiar. January is a difficult market. Opportunities are limited. The right deal wasn’t there.

Blah. Blah. Blah.

This summer, though, things were supposed to be different. The club was on a more stable footing. We finally had a coherent transfer strategy. There was a plan.

Yet as pre-season training got underway, that right-back berth remained unfilled.

Well, there’s been a World Cup. The market hasn’t really started yet. Plenty of time.

Blah. Blah. Blah.

Then came Saturday, 29 August 2026.

Selling Everton by the pound

Most Evertonians were settling down with a morning coffee when David Ornstein posted on X that Everton had accepted Nottingham Forest’s bid for Harrison Armstrong.

Across Merseyside, coffee was being sprayed over breakfast tables as angry Blues struggled to believe what they were reading.

Harrison Armstrong. One of the brightest prospects to emerge from the academy in years. A player many supporters had already earmarked as a big part of Everton’s future. And with just days remaining in the transfer window, the club appeared ready to cash in.

Suddenly, all that talk of stability, planning and long-term thinking sounded horribly familiar.

If the bid had been higher, and if the club involved had been different, there might have been more understanding from supporters.

But Nottingham Forest?

Fuck right off.

It’s one thing selling the family silver to one of the so-called Big Six. Fans may not like it, but at least they can understand the financial reality. Selling one of the crown jewels to a club that has spent most of this century looking up at Everton was something else entirely. It felt like a slap in the face.

Within hours, the travelling support at Bournemouth had made their feelings known. Chants aimed at the board rang around the away end, with a clear warning that if Armstrong was sold, there would be consequences. The backlash was immediate. The fury was impossible to ignore.

Then, less than 24 hours later, came the U-turn. Everton announced that Nottingham Forest’s offer had been rejected. Which was welcome news, of course. But it also raised a far more troubling question: how had the club found itself in this position in the first place?

Plus ça change

In some respects, Kinnear and the Definitely Not a Transfer Committee lost more of my respect with that decision because it showed them to be weak. In my opinion, left Kinnear’s position perilous.

Still, all was not lost for Angus Kinnear. Two days of the transfer window remained, offering an opportunity to salvage an increasingly embarrassing situation.

Then Sunday afternoon arrived.

News broke that Everton had accepted a £60 million bid for Iliman N’diaye. At the same time, reports emerged that former Everton hero Richarlison would be returning to the club in a separate deal. The reaction was predictable. Confusion quickly gave way to disbelief.

Once again, the Definitely Not a Transfer Committee appeared to demonstrate a remarkable lack of judgement and negotiating ability. In a market where distinctly, average players were being sold for eye-watering sums, Everton seemed willing to part with their most influential player for what felt like a bargain-bin fee. And not to a Champions League contender. Not to one of Europe’s elite. To a club that had finished 17th in consecutive Premier League seasons.

Sixty million pounds may sound like a substantial sum in isolation, but modern football does not operate in isolation. By current market standards, Everton were preparing to sell their crown jewel for little more than the going rate of mediocrity. 

Then, on Bank Holiday Monday, news began to emerge that the Richarlison deal was in doubt. Confusion reigned. Some reports suggested he had been unable to agree personal terms with Everton. Others claimed Tottenham were refusing to pay money still owed to him before sanctioning the move.

Then came Richarlison’s Instagram post. He spoke of being treated badly during the negotiations and made it clear where his heart lay. His heart, he said, was at Everton. Now, for most Definitely Not a Transfer Committees, that might have been interpreted as a sign that a deal was there to be done if only, they were willing to find a way. Apparently not ours.

“After everything I’ve been through in the last few years, I have decided that never again would others decide my future for me.

“I’ve been through a lot of bad things in this time and almost all of them have happened because of decisions made by other people. Pressure, threats, retaliation – none of that scares me. I’ve been through worse, believe me!

“I’ve always made it clear at every opportunity that if I were to leave for another team, it would also have to be good for the club. If it wasn’t, I would never accept it… just as I didn’t accept it when everything here was falling apart and they needed me.”

“I stayed and gave my all. So, I hope you’ll treat my situation with the same respect that I’ve always had for the Spurs and for everyone who’s worked with me during this time. Just don’t try to decide for me.

“If an agreement is reached between Spurs and Everton I’ll return to the team I love. My intention was indeed to return to the place where I was so happy.

“But the negotiations weren’t going the way people wanted and it’s not going to be that way anymore. Despite all this turmoil, I have a contract with the Spurs and I’ll be at the club’s disposal.”

Richarlison’s message via Instagram stories

While uncertainty continued to surround Richarlison’s return, Manchester City submitted a slightly improved offer for Iliman Ndiaye. Everton accepted. A medical was scheduled for deadline day.

In the midst of all this, fresh rumours began to gather pace. Everton were reportedly pursuing Monaco striker Folarin Balogun, while Kenny Tete was said to be on his way, with both Manchester United and Fulham having accepted bids.

For a brief moment, it appeared there might actually be a plan. Sell your best player, replace him with an American international striker, finally sign a right-back and hope nobody noticed the smoke pouring from the engine room. It was hardly inspiring, but at least it resembled a strategy.

Then it was announced that Monaco had accepted Everton’s bid and that Folarin Balogun was heading to Merseyside for a medical. Grealish was already in the building, but the Kenny Tete deal was beginning to flounder as Fulham struggled to secure a replacement.

Then, as if we had somehow travelled back to the summer of 2021, the name Ainsley Maitland-Niles reappeared. Lyon had accepted a £4 million bid, and he too was headed to Finch Farm.

Then, like all frantic deadline days, there was radio silence. Negotiations had to be concluded, medicals completed and media commitments fulfilled. There was still no need to panic.

Then, at around 7pm, L’Équipe reported that the Balogun deal could be off. Panic spread like wildfire.

Suddenly the squad looked alarmingly thin. Beto, Patterson, Iroegbunam and Ndiaye were all on their way out, and Everton faced the very real prospect of playing the first four months of the season with just one recognised senior striker.

The response was suitably desperate. Everton moved for Manchester United flop Joshua Zirkzee, only to be rebuffed.

Shortly before the deadline the club announced the signing of Grealish and confirmed that a deal sheet had been submitted for Balogun. Fifteen minutes later came confirmation that Maitland-Niles had signed. To be fair, he is a right-back, just not the right-back we were promised.

At that point most Blues went to bed believing that, somehow, Everton had pulled it off. Three new signings, a replacement for Ndiaye seemingly on the way, and perhaps a squad that looked stronger than it had that morning.

We should have known better. Then we woke up.

Has it come to this?

Balogun hadn’t signed. He had walked out of Finch Farm still a Monaco player.

Everton were left with one senior striker and another who remains something of an enigma. Beyond them, the next option is an untested 18-year-old.

This morning, Finch Farm should have been hosting a post-mortem. Dan Friedkin should have been on the phone to Angus Kinnear demanding answers as to how the Definitely Not a Transfer Committee had managed to oversee such a catastrophic failure.

The squad now contains just 18 senior players. Not enough to fill the bench and nowhere near strong enough to compete over the course of a Premier League season. As for the cups? They are no longer anything close to a priority.

The only acceptable outcome should be the resignation of the Definitely Not a Transfer Committee. Through negligence, incompetence or sheer hubris, they have left the club in a position that would have been unthinkable just a few months ago.

Last year, Kinnear asked to be judged after two summer transfer windows.

Well, Angus, you have been judged.

And the verdict is incompetence.

Time is up.

It is time for you to go.

Words by John Wharton

Check out The Blue Room Everton podcast on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.

3 responses

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles